I know I’m a few years late, but I watched the Les Miserables movie recently. I’ve never even seen the musical before or read the novel. All I really knew was that it was supposed to be sad and depressing, and I tend to stay away from sad stories. I’m afraid that once I start crying, I won’t be able to stop.
The most moving scene in the movie for me was, of course, Anne Hathaway singing “I Dreamed a Dream.” I know I haven’t suffered anywhere close to what Anne Hathaway’s Fantine character had been through, but I think many of us can identify with the song, with losing our innocence and having our lives turn out much differently than what we had dreamed.
For me, the song brought back memories of the first boy I loved, a boy I dated on and off through college and a little after. He was my neighbor in our freshman dorm, and we bonded instantly when we first met. I had never felt so close to someone before, and I fell deeply in love with him.
I made a terrible decision though.
I knew he had a girlfriend back at home, but I allowed him to continue his long distance relationship with her as our close friendship evolved into intimacy. He told me that he wanted to break up with her in person, and I didn’t want to hurt her. If only I had been a stronger person, I would have told him that I couldn’t be with him until he was single. I know what I did was wrong, and I’ll always regret it.
I avoided thinking about his girlfriend our freshman year, never knowing what was really going on with them. I wanted to be cool and not nag him about breaking up with her, and simply hoped that one day he would. During our winter break, he came to visit me for a few days and met my parents, but when we returned to school in January, he still hadn’t broken up with her. Yet we continued our college romance, even saying the words “I love you” to each other for the first time.
Shortly after, my father suddenly passed away. I can’t even begin to describe how devastated I felt when that happened, so I won’t go into it here, it’s a little too personal. After that happened, I decided that I HAD to be with with this college boy, because he would be the only boyfriend from now on who had met my father. My father had seemed like he liked him and approved of him too, so I thought this boy must be The One. I began to dream of our lives and future together, and I couldn’t imagine myself with anyone else.
After our freshman year ended and we returned to our respective hometowns for the summer, we talked frequently on the phone, by email, and instant messaging. Early on that summer, I summoned the courage to ask him about his girlfriend, if their relationship was over, and he made it sound like it was. Whatever he told me, I completely trusted. I fell in love with him more and more that summer, and I remember how happy I was when he visited me, how beautiful and special I felt when he held me and told me how lucky he was to have me. He was my soul mate, and I thought we had been destined to be together.
I was excited to start our sophomore year as a couple, but everything started feeling off from the beginning. He began to pick on me and criticize me constantly. We were in the same chemistry class, and he would become furious with me if I received a better grade on a test, so I actually started purposefully writing in wrong answers on the tests. I remember obsessing over how I looked before each class, because I wanted to look my best so he would keep loving me. He started acting more and more cruel to me, but I was so hopelessly in love and devoted to him. Any self esteem or confidence that I had completely eroded away, and I always felt like I was never good enough for him.
The day before we left for our winter break that year, he came to my dorm room in a dark mood and barely spoke to me. I had made a little candle holder for him as a Christmas present and decorated it with penguins, which I gave to him hoping it would help cheer him up. Instead, he looked at it and began crying, telling me that he didn’t think we should be together anymore. I cried too and felt completely shattered. I miss the girl I was before that moment, who was naive and innocent, who fell in love completely, who showed her vulnerable side when she gave the boy she loved the little candle holder.
He slept a summer by my side
He filled my days with endless wonder
He took my childhood in his stride
But he was gone when autumn came
I recovered a little as I spent time at home during the winter break and began to gain some independence back. It was difficult when we returned to school, because we had isolated ourselves from other friends, but I tried hard to spend time apart from him even though he was my best friend. He soon began to flirt with me again, and the flirtations kept increasing. I got my hopes up and dreamed that we would be back together soon, and on Valentine’s day he instant messaged me about going out to dinner that evening. I was over the moon as we finalized plans for the date, but then he made a mistake that changed everything.
Somehow, he accidentally copied and pasted a conversation he was having with his “ex” girlfriend into our chat window, and I discovered that he was still with her, that they had never broken up. I was completely blindsided and heartbroken all over again. At that moment I cut off all communication with him.
After a couple of months of not speaking, I began dating a new guy, and the college boy wrote me a letter declaring his love for me and apologizing for everything he had done. He told me that I was the one he imagined he would marry someday. We slowly became friends again, and after many months of him telling me that he loved me and that he was no longer with his girlfriend back home, I finally gave in and got back together with him.
And I still dream he’ll come to me
That we will live the years together
But there are dreams that cannot be
And there are storms we cannot weather
We entered a terribly destructive cycle that continued for several more years – I’d find out that he was still with the other girl, I’d break up with him, I’d start dating someone else, he couldn’t handle me being with anyone but him, he would beg me to come back to him, and I always did. I completely changed over this time, and I’m extremely embarrassed and regretful of some of my actions. After he treated me so cruelly, unfortunately I reacted by being cruel to others around me. I became a cynical and negative person, just like him. I started hating myself and feeling stupid, inept, and ugly all of the time, and I built up walls to protect my vulnerable side, because I didn’t believe that anyone could actually like the real me anymore.
The last time I stopped talking to him, I still hoped that he would try to win me back again, but part of me knew this time it was for good. We were no longer in college together or even living in the same state. It really hurt that he had been my best friend for so long, but he didn’t care about trying to keep in touch with me anymore. Now I realize that it was for the best, as we would have never been happy together after how much pain we had put each other through, and if we had stayed in touch the destructive cycle would have never ended. I would have never been able to trust him, and he would have always made me feel like I wasn’t good enough.
Recently, I looked him up on social media for the first time since I stopped talking to him almost 8 years ago. He is married to that same girl he had cheated on with me for years, and they have a son together. I wonder if he thinks of me, and if he’s happy with how everything turned out for him. I’m guessing he is.
I’m married now too, to someone who is nothing like him, someone who is committed and supportive of me, who is optimistic and sees the best in people. I feel more at peace now, but I still don’t think I’ve recovered from the serious blows to my self esteem and trust over those years.
I let that destructive relationship define me for a long time and held on to the pain for too long, but I’m feeling less anger toward him now. We were young and immature, and we acted without considering all of the consequences. I wish he hadn’t been so cruel to me over those years, constantly making me feel like I wasn’t good enough, especially when I was weak after losing my father. I still wonder what would have happened if I hadn’t started a relationship with him while he had a girlfriend, but I’ll never know. I hope at least that he has changed into someone who wouldn’t cheat on his wife, and I hope that he feels guilty about his actions back then too.